Kunochan
Member
Registered: Jun 2000
Location: Los Angeles, CA
Posts: 3 |
Wow. I haven't seen a discussion thread this vituperative (and, therefore, interesting) since I was in charge of AOL's Atheism Board. Here are my two cents, for which I demand a 15 cent licensing fee from anyone who reads this text (sorry, it's too late, you already owe me):
Footski's theory makes a lot of sense. Even if it's true, however, Bob the Inventor's legal actions against competing companies still amount to an unethical (even if legal) business practice, but one that is practiced thousands of times a day in America.
It's similar to what is referred to in consumer protection law as a "SLAPP" suit, a "Strategic Lawsuit Against Public Partcipation." In this case, one entity (usually a large corporation with endless resources) sues another entity (usually an individual with few resources), as a method of silencing the second entity's First Ammendment right to criticize the first entity. The lawsuit can be entirely baseless; that's not the point, because it's never meant to come to trial. It's a simple case of "we have more money than you, so shut up or we'll make your life miserable." Unfortunately, in most cases, this works. (To see an example where it didn't, check out http://www.spanner.org/mclibel/)
In this case, the same technique is being used as an anti-competitive business practice. The small businesses that Bob attacks don't have the legal resources to fight his claim, no matter how weak the claim may be. He can put his competitors out of business with a single letter, because no one wants to risk bankruptcy by fighting this guy.
BTW, I don't think anyone has mentioned that Bob seems to be building a pyramid scheme, "allowing" kids to cut pieces of plastic into rectangles in exchange for a cut of their profits.
A final note to Bob: My Coleman� Brand wristwatch came with a peel-off plastic cover over the face; also, my Audiovox cell phone has a removable plastic cover too. You should sue those guys.
------------------
*****
Erik David Even
"You have to know that
someday you will die.
Until you know that, you
are worthless." � Tyler
Durden
|