tuffy
Member
Registered: Feb 2000
Location:
Posts: 70 |
prism vs ipaq screen
Let me start by saying that I own a Orange VDx, and have no plans to switch in the near future. That said, I went out to my local Best Buy today hoping for a look at the screen on the Prism. James' review is very positive, but after talking to another user over the phone about his impressions of the Prism screen. The color depth was not an issue but he made some other comments in regards to the resolution of the screen. Because of the limitations of the 160x160 res, he said for example that a simple shape, such as a circle, could not be rendered without jagged edges. He also said that even at arms length, a black grid was visible between the pixels.
Although I was not able to see the Prism at Best Buy, I grudgingly asked to see the Ipaq they had on display. I can see why this device is so highly coveted now. Again, don't get me wrong, I am a HUGE Visor advocate, and have personally been responsible for at least 4 visor purchases among friends and co-workers, and have several others strongly considering a purchase. I did not even want to like any pocket pc, but I came away from that store fairly impressed with what I saw. the screen was very clear from every angle I viewed it from, and I'm told it is the same in direct sunlight although I didn't get to test this. The unit comes with a media player for music (maybe videos too??), a built in mic & voice recorder, and pocket versions of word & excel along with standard PIM apps. Overall it is quite a nice package. I didn't really like the way the interface worked, but that could be because I am used to the simple interface of PALM.
The point of all this is value. Sure the Ipaq lists for $499, but you get a truckload of features for that price. Loading up a visor with just an mp3 player & voice recorder (two items I am interested in) would cost considerably more. With the base price of the prism at $449, I think it is overpriced. If the screen is not comparable to the Ipaq, then it is grossly overpriced. I think that $349 would make it worthwhile, but I need to see the screen to be sure. If there are any prism owners who have seen the ipaq & prism side by side, I would love to hear your impressions!!!
So where does this leave me? Considering the investment I have already made (stowaway, backup & soundsgood, vaja case, and several apps) I think the platinum is the next machine for me, especially if they drop the price to $250 or less. I will reserve final judgment until I actually see the prism screen, but right now, I think if I had to have color, I would want at least a 320x320 resolution along with 16 bit color. Maybe Palm OS 4 will address this (and considering how the Ipaq screen looks, maybe Palm better)
In the near future, I will be sticking with my trusty VDx and waiting for the total recall, geode, blue connect, and keeping my ear to the ground for news on higher resolution for the palm platform. Are there any prism owners out there with other opinions? If so, please share...
__________________
tuffy
|