Madkins007
Member
Registered: Mar 2001
Location: Nebraska- the Good life
Posts: 695 |
I got my new Tactilis FlipLid today, and just replaced my FlipCover with it.
My impressions so far are:
Color: I have an Ice VDX, and have been using green accessories because they go so well together (they harmonize with the green circuit board visible through the case). The FlipCover's green is a close match to the circuit boards, and a bit bluer than the green stylus. The Tactilis is yellower- almost a bright lime color. Still a decent match, but brighter than I would have expected.
Lid fit: The FlipCover fits low and snug, similar to the original snap cover. The Tactilis 'floats' about 3/16" above the screen, but flexes easily downwards, which may provide some shock absorbtion. It is a bit wider than the VDX to allow for the side-mounted hinges and adds about 3/16 to both sides. The lower edge fits closely with a 'hill' for a thumb or finger catch 9although i find that I open it by catching a side and flipping it like a Star Trek (Original Series) communicator. Both lids seem to prevent accidental button pushes.
Hinges: The Tactilis side-mounting hinges allow the use of most modules, but only allows the lid to open 1/2 of the way, while the FlipCover goes all the way back. Honestly- big deal. All the way back makes it hard to lay it on a table to use, while the Tactilis can be used as a sunscreen to an extent. On the other hand, the FlipCover's hinges do not add hardly anything to the overall size of the unit. Both hinges seem about equally durable (or flimsy).
Interesting features: I like the way the Tactilis holds in either a 1/4 or a 1/2 open state. The 1/4 open state is pretty handy. I like the little compartment the FlipCover uses to snap into the Visor- if I could just figure out what to store in there! I also like the cool one-finger flip-open ability fo the Tactilis, and the wrist-flip closing of the FlipCover. The FlipCover works great if you are using a pouch or holster since it is so smooth and close-fitting, but the Tactilis lets you use the Visor in cases that use the original snap-cover as a holder. An odd point would be that you could scribe a vertical line in the middle of the Tactilis to help you use compasses or GPS software better (the line would help act as a sighting guide).
Overall: I think both are decent, and nicely priced. I would use the Tactilis if I am routinely using a module that the FlipCover's glue-on hinge cannot work on (SoundsGood, CF or SM card modules, etc.), or if I were using a case that the Visor snapped into.
I would use the FlipCover for holsters, people not routinely using modules or using 'flat-top' modules, etc.
Odd stuff file: You can use both at the same time! Reverse the lid on the FlipCover so it goes on the back (it will not latch) and you got both sides covered! (I have NO idea WHY you would do something this dumb, but then again, I did it!)
|