PDAENVY
Member

Registered: Nov 1999
Location: Ann Arbor, Michigan USA
Posts: 790 |
quote: Originally posted by dick-richardson
People advocating death in this instance are rather short sighted. I was talking to a friend of mine (who spent some time in a federal pen), and sex offenders do not have an easy time of it. Imagine something sick and twisted, turn it up a couple notches, make it a little more depraved, and they get to experience it frequently. Even more so if children are involved. A lifetime of that would suffice nicely.
The question in my mind is, do we want:
A. to make sure he will never do it again?
B. to get retribution on him?
For A, death works, as would life in prison, except that it seems that child sex abusers have a hellish and probably short life in the pen. There seems to be some debate as to whether castration (traditional or chemical) is preventative.
For B, we're generaly limited by the Bill of Rights's limitation on "cruel and unusual punishment", but time in a federal pen sounds like he'd suffer plenty. Does anyone know if a pedophile has ever asked for solitary on the basis that being tortured by the general prison population is cruel and unusual punishment?
__________________
Jeff
|