news | articles | reviews | software | modules | accessories | discussion | faq | mobile | store
VisorCentral.com >> Discussion >> Other Areas of Interest >> Off Topic
ADHD: real or BS?

Post a New Thread | Post A Reply

Arduous Development Happens Dynamically.
You do not have permission to vote on this poll.
Pardon? What was the question? 6 33.33%
I can't hold still long enough to type. 12 66.67%
Total: 18 votes 100%
  [Edit Poll (moderators only)]

Pages (8): « 1 [2] 3 4 5 6 7 » ... Last »   Last Thread   Next Thread
Author
Topic: ADHD: real or BS?    Pages (8): « 1 [2] 3 4 5 6 7 » ... Last »
Toby
Member

Registered: Jul 2000
Location:
Posts: 3034

quote:
Originally posted by dick-richardson
[re: shrink]
Does that term bug you guys?



Personally, I always connote 'shrink' as only referring to psychiatrists (since they can directly prescribe something to shrink your head). Skull-f*ck*rs would refer to the more general class.

Toby is offline Old Post 06-19-2001 01:10 PM
Click Here to See the Profile for Toby Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
LarryN
Member

Registered: Jun 2000
Location: Pembroke,MA
Posts: 307

quote:
Originally posted by Toby
...Skull-f*ck*rs would refer to the more general class.


I've never kill-filed anybody in any forum, but this place has generally been a lot more civil than most, thanks to thoughtful moderation by the staff, without resorting to Big Brotherisms. You directly detract from VisorCentral in my book. It seems there's nothing you will not stoop to just to say something, and to make sure you get the last word in at any cost. Your comments, like the above one, are not jokes, no matter how many smiles you place next to the cut down.

<PLONK>

Now, I know I will enjoy VC more without the extra drivel. IMHO, Off-Topic does not mean that anybody has carte blanche to say whatever they want to about others. You are simply being destructive to this group.

LarryN is offline Old Post 06-19-2001 01:28 PM
Click Here to See the Profile for LarryN Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
homer
Member

Registered: Jan 2000
Location: Twin Cities, MN
Posts: 1683

Whoa. What's with everyone giving Toby so much flak? LarryN...I think you took the thread more off-topic than he did.

__________________
We're all naked if you turn us inside out.
-David Byrne

homer is offline Old Post 06-19-2001 05:21 PM
Click Here to See the Profile for homer Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
dick-richardson
Member

Registered: Oct 2000
Location: Aberdeen, SD
Posts: 2531

quote:
Originally posted by homer
Whoa. What's with everyone giving Toby so much flak?

It's chic. All the cool kids are doing it.
quote:
Originally posted by LarryN
Now, I know I will enjoy VC more without the extra drivel.

Anything to make you happy. Can we keep my thread?
quote:
It seems there's nothing you will not stoop to just to say something , and to make sure you get the last word in at any cost.


That's rather funny. My experience with Toby has been that he ignores most of the drivel in the forums. His posts are intelligent and thought-out.
quote:
Your comments, like the above one, are not jokes, no matter how many smiles you place next to the cut down.


Interesting. I'm of the opposite opinion - namely that people need to have sense of humor. There is a big difference between a blatant flame and ribbing that's meant good-naturedly. Of course you don't want to remove all the humor from VC, just the humor that you find offensive. I am of the opinion that if the humor isn't of your liking, you can ignore it - as opposed to advocating a restriction of the type of humor that's allowed here. If someone is offended, it's their responsibility to speak up. They don't need you to do it for them. You're right, the mods do a damn fine job. You aren't one of them. Let them work. I often wonder if Ambrose Bierce or Oscar Wilde would get anything published were they alive, considering today's PC BS whiny society.

__________________
-Joshua
Abortion: Darwinism at its finest.

dick-richardson is offline Old Post 06-19-2001 05:47 PM
Click Here to See the Profile for dick-richardson Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
dick-richardson
Member

Registered: Oct 2000
Location: Aberdeen, SD
Posts: 2531

headgamer, my shrink is a psychologist, so can I assume that he isn't going to want to drug me? Drugs are not an option.

homer, what exactly would the advantages of AD(h)D be? Not being able to sit still or pay attention doesn't seem too wonderful to me. My wife is getting irritated having to find everything I lost, not to mention that I tell her I'll help out around the house, but she doesn't let me know when she's starting (because I should be able to see that she's cleaning/washing/etc. and if I really wanted to help I would).

Are the questionaires I had to fill out (and have my wife and mother fill out, too) sufficient enough to diagnose ADHD? If it's biological, where's the litmus test? If it's mental, I can do it on my own. Why should I have to start taking medication at 22? If I have ADHD, I've had my entire life, and I'm still going strong. How's that truism about fixing things that aren't broken go?

__________________
-Joshua
Abortion: Darwinism at its finest.

dick-richardson is offline Old Post 06-19-2001 06:13 PM
Click Here to See the Profile for dick-richardson Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
dick-richardson
Member

Registered: Oct 2000
Location: Aberdeen, SD
Posts: 2531

Is my son going to get it (if I have it)?

__________________
-Joshua
Abortion: Darwinism at its finest.

dick-richardson is offline Old Post 06-19-2001 06:18 PM
Click Here to See the Profile for dick-richardson Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
dick-richardson
Member

Registered: Oct 2000
Location: Aberdeen, SD
Posts: 2531

headgamer, are you going to send me a bill?

__________________
-Joshua
Abortion: Darwinism at its finest.

dick-richardson is offline Old Post 06-19-2001 06:21 PM
Click Here to See the Profile for dick-richardson Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
septimus
VisorCentral Staff

Registered: Feb 2001
Location: Them Twin Cities
Posts: 1758

....4 posts in a row....

....aya....

...I'm interesed in the heridity question too...


<off topic>
D-R, what's you sig, "-josh" mean?
</off topic>

As I read through these symptoms, I'm getting a little worried...

...Does ADHD affect memory?

__________________
Don't like somebody? Click "Profile" on a post and then click "Ignore "so and so's" posts". Voila!

septimus is offline Old Post 06-19-2001 06:28 PM
Click Here to See the Profile for septimus Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
dick-richardson
Member

Registered: Oct 2000
Location: Aberdeen, SD
Posts: 2531

quote:
Originally posted by dietrichbohn
<off topic>
D-R, what's you sig, "-josh" mean?
</off topic>


It's my name.

__________________
-Joshua
Abortion: Darwinism at its finest.

dick-richardson is offline Old Post 06-19-2001 06:33 PM
Click Here to See the Profile for dick-richardson Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
homer
Member

Registered: Jan 2000
Location: Twin Cities, MN
Posts: 1683

quote:
homer, what exactly would the advantages of AD(h)D be?


First off, go get that book...driven to distraction...it answers a lot of these questions.

The advantages of ADD is that you probably tend to focus on certain things to an extreme. In my case, I am a designer (artist). A LOT of people with ADD end up as artists of some sort.

Throughout my school years, I was extremely good at school, but doing homework was (and still is) an agonizing process. When I went to college and found myself as an art major, I was all of the sudden extremely focused on art. I could work on a project for hours upon hours at a time.

The disadvantages are that I simply am not good at things like paperwork, budgeting, etc..., but I tend to be very good at visualization and creative work.

quote:
Not being able to sit still or pay attention doesn't seem too wonderful to me.


Its not. I am terrible in meetings. I last maybe 20 minutes. In hindsight, this was the way I was in school as well. I wouldn't absorb much from a lecture class...my mind would be off entertaining itself in about 15 minutes.

quote:
Are the questionaires I had to fill out (and have my wife and mother fill out, too) sufficient enough to diagnose ADHD?


I can't answer that. However, it has been shown that the people that can best diagnose you, or, at least recognize the syptoms, are those that interact with you everyday (such as your wife). That's why childhood ADD should first be recognize by a trained teacher. I think too many parents try and diagnose their own kids, but these are the parents that see their kids from only 6-9 pm evernight where the kids are begging for attention.

In my case, the tests I was taking made little sense to me until afterwords. Basically, they were a variety of things to make sure there weren't other problems existing. They were able to cross out depression, anxiety, learning disabilities, etc..

In my case, it came down to ADD being the ONLY probably cause of my problems, as they were able to weed out any other variables.

Accoring to my psychologist, the most telling test was the one me and my wife took...they were pretty much identical.

quote:
If it's biological, where's the litmus test?


From what I understand, there isn't one today, but in a decade or so, they may be able to identify ADD via a catscan. (it is an imbalance in the brain).

quote:
If it's mental, I can do it on my own.


To a point. It's good to have a 'coach'. My problem is that I can IDENTIFY times when my ADD is acting up (when I interupt people, when I get fidgety in a meeting, etc...) but I still tend to catch myself AFTER the fact. Which is frustrating.

quote:
Why should I have to start taking medication at 22?


The same reason that you should wear glasses if your eyes are going at 22.

Medication isn't necessarily bad, just an option.

I'm going to look into it with my doctor. I have a friend who was diagnosed at 30 and he said medication made a world of difference for him. He is no longer on it, as he has developed coping skills now.

quote:
If I have ADHD, I've had my entire life, and I'm still going strong. How's that truism about fixing things that aren't broken go?


Exactly, if it isn't a problem for you, why worry? That said, it sounds like it may be a problem for your wife...so you should at least look into your options.

quote:
Is my son going to get it (if I have it)?


ADD is hereditary. I'm 100% sure that my father has some form of it. He's developed EXTREME coping skills in his life. He forces him to do one thing at a time. He can't even think about the second thing until the first one is done. It is somewhat humorous to watch him get through a conversation at times.

Again, go read that book. It will answer a LOT of questions for you (and probably bring up a lot more!)

__________________
We're all naked if you turn us inside out.
-David Byrne

homer is offline Old Post 06-19-2001 06:37 PM
Click Here to See the Profile for homer Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
headgamer
Member

Registered: Apr 2001
Location: Bismarck, ND
Posts: 114

quote:
Originally posted by dick-richardson
headgamer, my shrink is a psychologist, so can I assume that he isn't going to want to drug me? Drugs are not an option.

[snip]

Are the questionnaires I had to fill out (and have my wife and mother fill out, too) sufficient enough to diagnose ADHD? If it's biological, where's the litmus test? If it's mental, I can do it on my own. Why should I have to start taking medication at 22? If I have ADHD, I've had my entire life, and I'm still going strong. How's that truism about fixing things that aren't broken go?



As far as I know there are no states that allow for prescription privileges for psychologist (yet - some states have legislation in process though). So no, he won't be prescribing you any meds. That does NOT mean he won't want to refer you to a psychiatrist for a medication consult, though.

When it comes to psychological illnesses and issues, there rarely *IS* a litmus test. It's not like most physical disabilities where they can take a blood test or whatever to say, "Yeah, you've got X." As someone mentioned before, that doesn't mean they don't exist; it just means psychological disorders are based in the brain which is such a complex construct that at this point it is near impossible to find that elusive "litmus test". That is why most psychological diagnoses are made via clinical interview and testing - the diagnosis is INFERRED based on history, clinical presentation, and behavior. Psychological diagnosis is as much an art as it is a science (at least at this point). Most evaluations that I do for ADHD do involve questionnaires, both for the individual, family, (and in most cases school officials), a computer test for attention, concentration, and impulsivity, and a good clinical interview - usually both with the individual and family.

Regarding ADHD and litmus tests, the closest thing to a litmus test is simply your response to medication. The nice thing about most meds these days is that they are getting much more specific about the areas/chemicals in the brain they affect. This results in fewer and less severe side effects, and focuses specifically on the symptoms at hand. Regarding ADHD, I have known psychologists/psychiatrists that have inferred an ADHD diagnosis on smaller children (where testing is more difficult) based on their response to ADHD-oriented medications. This is not always a bad thing. If your symptoms improve significantly on medications, there's one more piece of evidence weighing in toward ADHD. If not, it suggests that something else is contributing toward your symptom presentation. A one- or two-month trial on a medication for ADHD symptoms may be helpful, if for no other reason than to help provide more information to rule in or out the appropriateness of the ADHD diagnosis.

I don't really see adults with ADHD as being an "it it ain't broke, don't fix it" kind of issue. I see it more as a "buggy software" kind of issue. The software runs, but crashes every now and then and doesn't always run efficiently. Does that mean the software is unusable and worthless? Absolutely not. Would it run better if a good patch were available? Absolutely yes. If a patch which resolved the bugs and made things run more smoothly with fewer crashes was available, would you use it? Probably so.

Hope that helps.

And btw, Toby. At least you used asterisks when you referred to me and my colleagues as Skull-F*****s. That I guess shows some restraint.

__________________
J. Sean McKay, Ph.D.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
"In every work of genius....
we recognize our own rejected thoughts."
--Ralph Waldo Emerson
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

headgamer is offline Old Post 06-19-2001 06:42 PM
Click Here to See the Profile for headgamer Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
gbgood
Member

Registered: Dec 2000
Location: June 10, 2001 San Clemente Pier , CA
Posts: 211

The 'Driven to Distraction' book and it's partner, again I apologize but the name escapes me. I'm sure it's in these posts or on Amazon, are incredible for confirming in writing, actual occurances in your life. You will find yourself saying, "yeah, that's me."

I'm sure your ADHD behavior has often made your wife wonder if you:
*are doing it on purpose
*are stupid
*are just an as*h**e.
This is almost 'word for word' in those 2 books!
I really don't mean to be crass just trying to be direct. If you really have ADD/ADHD, you know exactly what I'm talking about here. The rest of you guys are just really as*h**es sometimes.

*That's why* these 2 books are also great for wives(mostly men are afflicted)to read.
For us wives, it really helps us to understand more of the thinking/coping process and how to help/understand/coach our husband and sons.

Now, if they just had drugs for wives.

It's been mentioned here as in those books, that a visor is an excellent tool for those with ADD/ADHD!

gbgood is offline Old Post 06-19-2001 07:28 PM
Click Here to See the Profile for gbgood Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
SpeakerCoach
Member

Registered: Sep 2000
Location:
Posts: 142

Cool Another thought

ADHD? I, too, laughed out loud when I looked at the sheet (given to us when we visit my step son's psychiatrist/psychologist/shrink) and realized that I do posses some (if not most) of those listed.

I was not born here in this country (where everything seems to have a quick-fix solution to, my personal opinion) and am doing well professionally (IS Consulting) without any drugging.

Too many studies, "professional" opinions are giving us some doubts of what kind of illness we have! I tend to be forgetfull at time, however by using the VPL (ToDoPlus, before that Franklin Planner) I am able to track my work without any problems.

So, if anyone is telling you that you have ADHD and as long as you are capable to perform your day-to-day tasks, I would not bother with any medicine at all.

That's my 2-penny thought!

SpeakerCoach is offline Old Post 06-19-2001 07:53 PM
Click Here to See the Profile for SpeakerCoach Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
septimus
VisorCentral Staff

Registered: Feb 2001
Location: Them Twin Cities
Posts: 1758

quote:
Originally posted by dick-richardson

It's my name.



Your name ain't Dick?? <<World tilts crazily on its axis>>

__________________
Don't like somebody? Click "Profile" on a post and then click "Ignore "so and so's" posts". Voila!

septimus is offline Old Post 06-19-2001 08:00 PM
Click Here to See the Profile for septimus Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
dick-richardson
Member

Registered: Oct 2000
Location: Aberdeen, SD
Posts: 2531

quote:
Originally posted by dietrichbohn


Your name ain't Dick?? <<World tilts crazily on its axis>>


Nope. I don't know know dick.

__________________
-Joshua
Abortion: Darwinism at its finest.

dick-richardson is offline Old Post 06-19-2001 09:57 PM
Click Here to See the Profile for dick-richardson Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
Toby
Member

Registered: Jul 2000
Location:
Posts: 3034

quote:
Originally posted by LarryN
I've never kill-filed anybody in any forum, but this place has generally been a lot more civil than most, thanks to thoughtful moderation by the staff, without resorting to Big Brotherisms.


Do you feel better now?

quote:
You directly detract from VisorCentral in my book.



Hmmm...I'm guessing you missed the humor there. It should be noted that the term was used by several of my psych professors (my degree is in management, and the curriculum allowed me enough psych and sociology electives that I would have qualified for a minor had they been available) in a humorous manner. Now perhaps headgamer is one of those mal-adjusted psychologists who would take my reference the wrong way and assume I meant offense, but my impression is that he's a bit more grounded than that.

quote:
It seems there's nothing you will not stoop to just to say something,



Funny, but I see a pretty low percentage of threads with 'bulletholes' when I'm looking at all the unread posts here.

quote:
and to make sure you get the last word in at any cost.



I really don't have time to bother, but I'm sure there are quite a few threads I've participated in where I didn't have the last word. Don't let evidence get in the way of your conclusions, though.

quote:
Your comments, like the above one, are not jokes, no matter how many smiles you place next to the cut down.



Are you a psychologist? Do you know any? Do you know any with a sense of humor?

quote:
<PLONK>



Interesting thing to choose to include in our first interaction. C'est la vie.

quote:
Now, I know I will enjoy VC more without the extra drivel.



"Whatever gets you through the night..."

quote:
IMHO, Off-Topic does not mean that anybody has carte blanche to say whatever they want to about others.



I agree.

quote:
You are simply being destructive to this group.



Well, if you're lying about having 'kill-filed' me, then perhaps you'll do me the kindness of substantiating your claim of how exactly I'm being destructive to the group.

edited for a missing word and a weirdly constructed sentence

Last edited by Toby on 06-19-2001 at 10:51 PM

Toby is offline Old Post 06-19-2001 10:18 PM
Click Here to See the Profile for Toby Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
Toby
Member

Registered: Jul 2000
Location:
Posts: 3034

quote:
Originally posted by dick-richardson

It's chic. All the cool kids are doing it.



You mean if I want to be cool, I have to start trying to assassinate my own character? A bit too MPD for my tastes.

quote:
That's rather funny. My experience with Toby has been that he ignores most of the drivel in the forums. His posts are intelligent and thought-out.



Oh pshaw...I'm blushin'

quote:
I often wonder if Ambrose Bierce or Oscar Wilde would get anything published were they alive, considering today's PC BS whiny society.



One of my favorite Stephen King stories (an interesting little vignette called "Rage") would have never been published (and actually is the only one AFAIK that's been excluded from reprints) in today's society. Granted, King was the one who made the choice, but it still shouldn't have been necessary, IMO.

Toby is offline Old Post 06-19-2001 10:24 PM
Click Here to See the Profile for Toby Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
Toby
Member

Registered: Jul 2000
Location:
Posts: 3034

quote:
Originally posted by headgamer
As far as I know there are no states that allow for prescription privileges for psychologist (yet - some states have legislation in process though). So no, he won't be prescribing you any meds. That does NOT mean he won't want to refer you to a psychiatrist for a medication consult, though.


That's how most of the ones I know work things. Much better than the recent trends of GPs going all willy-nilly prescribing things (it should be noted that this is the over/mis-diagnosis that I was mainly referring to in my previous reference if anyone wasn't clear).

quote:
When it comes to psychological illnesses and issues, there rarely *IS* a litmus test.



IMO, this is a serious issue that needs to be addressed in the mental health field (or more accurately in the medical field as a whole). Now, obviously there are conditions in which behavioral therapy is the solution, but I feel that any time medicine comes into the picture, we need to step up the science behind its indications.

[stuff that I'm not going to address since it would be counterproductive]

quote:
And btw, Toby. At least you used asterisks when you referred to me and my colleagues as Skull-F*****s. That I guess shows some restraint.




Well, it was the preferred pejorative of a couple of my psych profs that I really liked, so I figured you'd either roll with it (since it wasn't directed at you), or you'd get uptight (which would suggest that I'd probably be better off not dealing with you in the future). You didn't seem to be the uptight type, so I figured there wouldn't be much harm (LarryN notwithstanding).

Incidentally, how much stock do you put in MBTI and do you think there's likely any correlation between temperament type and AD(H)D? The reason I ask is that I occasionally participate in an INTP mailing list, and AD(H)D and some similar conditions are a frequent topic of discussion.

edit: fixed a mangled quote

Toby is offline Old Post 06-19-2001 10:48 PM
Click Here to See the Profile for Toby Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
Toby
Member

Registered: Jul 2000
Location:
Posts: 3034

.

Toby is offline Old Post 06-19-2001 10:52 PM
Click Here to See the Profile for Toby Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
dick-richardson
Member

Registered: Oct 2000
Location: Aberdeen, SD
Posts: 2531

You better watch out. Dietrichbohn has a thing against 4 posts in a row.

__________________
-Joshua
Abortion: Darwinism at its finest.

dick-richardson is offline Old Post 06-19-2001 11:01 PM
Click Here to See the Profile for dick-richardson Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
All times are GMT. The time now is 06:03 PM. Post New Thread    Post A Reply
 Pages (8): « 1 [2] 3 4 5 6 7 » ... Last » Last Thread   Next Thread
[ Show a Printable Version | Email This Page to Someone! | Receive updates to this thread ]

Forum Jump:

Powered by: vBulletin Version 2.3.4
Copyright ©2000, 2001, Jelsoft Enterprises Limited.